Wills & probate guide · England & Wales

Testamentary Capacity: The Banks v Goodfellow Test

Testamentary capacity is the mental ability required to make a valid will. It is assessed in relation to the will and the relevant time, not simply by asking whether someone was elderly, ill or receiving care. Capacity disputes often require a careful reconstruction of events from professional records, medical evidence and witnesses. This guide explains what that investigation should address.

Testamentary Capacity: The Banks v Goodfellow Test

The Banks v Goodfellow test

The common-law test comes from Banks v Goodfellow (1870). In broad terms, the person must understand the nature of making a will and its effects, understand the extent of the property being disposed of, and comprehend and appreciate the claims of people they ought to consider. A disorder of mind must not poison their affections, pervert their sense of right or prevent the exercise of their natural faculties so as to influence the disposition.

These are practical requirements, not an examination demanding perfect recollection of every asset or family event. The complexity of the estate and proposed distribution matters. A straightforward will may require a different level of understanding from a complicated arrangement involving businesses, trusts and competing family interests.

A person is allowed to make choices others consider unkind or eccentric. The legal question is whether they could make the relevant decision freely and with the required understanding, not whether the judge or their relatives would have made a kinder will. Unfairness alone is not incapacity.

The Mental Capacity Act and proposed reform

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 provides a statutory framework for many decisions, including the Court of Protection’s jurisdiction concerning statutory wills. It has not simply replaced the common-law probate test. In Clitheroe v Bond [2021] EWHC 1102 (Ch), Falk J considered the competing arguments and explained why Banks v Goodfellow remained the governing test for testamentary capacity.

Clitheroe also examined delusional beliefs. Assessment requires attention to the belief’s nature, origin, evidential basis and persistence within the overall evidence. It is unsafe to treat every mistaken family belief as a legally relevant delusion, or to assume that a belief is irrelevant merely because nobody tried to argue the person out of it.

The Law Commission has recommended modernising wills law, including capacity rules, but a recommendation or draft Bill is not itself operative legislation. Its implementation table records the wills project as pending. For a disputed will, check the law applicable to its making rather than assuming a reform headline has already changed the test.

Dementia, fluctuating ability and the relevant date

Dementia does not automatically prevent a valid will. Its effects vary between people and over time. Someone may need assistance with daily living yet retain sufficient understanding for a particular will. Conversely, appearing sociable during a short visit does not establish the ability to evaluate a complicated disposition.

Identify when instructions were given, when drafts were approved and when the will was executed. Capacity at the relevant points needs analysis; there are limited principles concerning instructions given with capacity and later execution that require specialist consideration. Do not assume that a diagnosis made after signing proves incapacity beforehand.

Medication, delirium, depression, grief, pain and sensory difficulties can affect the evidence in different ways. A hearing impairment may explain an apparently confused response without proving cognitive incapacity. Medical notes should be read in context, alongside the professional’s purpose and the information available at the time. A general screening score is not a direct substitute for applying the legal test.

The golden rule and contemporary evidence

The golden rule associated with Kenward v Adams recommends medical involvement when an elderly or seriously ill person makes a will. The practitioner should be satisfied about capacity and understanding and record the examination and findings. It is a protective practice, not an additional statutory formality whose omission automatically invalidates a will.

Good contemporary evidence records the person’s own explanation of their assets, family and proposed choices. It should show how instructions were obtained, who was present, what alternatives were discussed and how any communication difficulties were addressed. A tick-box statement saying capacity satisfactory may be less useful than a detailed note of the actual conversation.

Following the golden rule does not make a will unchallengeable. A medical professional may have assessed the wrong question or lacked important information. Equally, an urgent will can be valid despite the absence of a formal report. The court evaluates all the evidence rather than treating the presence or absence of a certificate as decisive.

Burden of proof and retrospective expert reports

The person propounding the will bears the legal burden of establishing capacity. Where a will is rational on its face and duly executed, capacity may be presumed in the absence of real doubt. Evidence raising a real doubt requires the propounder to satisfy the court on the issue. How those principles operate depends on the facts and should be reflected accurately in the pleaded case.

Useful evidence can include the drafting file, earlier wills, GP and hospital notes, care records, medication history and witness accounts close to the relevant dates. Statements should describe observations rather than offer unsupported diagnoses. Preserve examples of clear reasoning as well as confusion: a balanced record is more credible than a collection selected solely to support the desired outcome.

A retrospective expert can help interpret the records and relate medical evidence to the legal questions. They cannot examine the deceased or fill missing evidence with certainty. Explain the limits of the material, consider whether expert evidence is proportionate and remember that court permission may be required to rely on it in proceedings. The final decision about capacity is for the court.

Practical steps for challengers and defenders

A prospective challenger should obtain the will and grant details, identify their interest in the outcome and create a dated chronology. Ask the will drafter focused questions, often through a Larke v Nugus request, and seek relevant medical material through proper channels. Avoid alleging incapacity simply because the distribution changed or a relative disliked the decision.

A person defending the will should preserve the complete drafting file, identify independent witnesses and explain the deceased’s reasoning where there is reliable evidence. Address contrary medical records rather than dismissing them. Capacity, knowledge and approval, and undue influence are separate questions: success on one issue does not automatically resolve all the others.

A contentious probate or Chancery barrister can assess the evidential gaps, settle expert questions and advise whether litigation is proportionate. Direct Access may suit an early opinion or hearing, but most Direct Access barristers do not conduct litigation; a solicitor may be needed to obtain records and manage proceedings. Clerk & Counsel is an intermediary and clerking service matching clients with independent barristers, not the provider of legal advice or representation.

Cost guide

Estimate the likely cost of a barrister

A broad guide based on fees typically quoted by barristers in England and Wales. Choose the options closest to your case to see a realistic range.

Estimated barrister's fee

£2,000 to £3,350 plus VAT

About £2,400 to £4,000 including VAT at 20%, where the barrister is VAT registered.

What the estimate covers

  • Reading and preparing your papers before the hearing
  • A conference with you beforehand, by phone, video or in person
  • Preparing submissions, a skeleton argument or position statement where needed
  • Attending and representing you at the hearing
  • A short note of the outcome and next steps afterwards

Why your quote may differ

Your quote will depend on which suitable barristers are available for your hearing date. It also depends on how many papers there are, how complex the case is and the amount at stake.

Senior barristers and King's Counsel are usually only needed for complex, high value or specialist cases. Short-notice hearings cost more because the barrister has to clear time to prepare.

Hearings of a week or more, written advice and drafting are quoted individually. Court fees, expert fees and travel are not included.

The Clerk & Counsel service fee of up to £150, depending on urgency, is separate. It is shown alongside the barrister's fee before you decide whether to go ahead. Submitting an enquiry is free.

FAQs

Common questions

Can someone with dementia make a will?

Yes, if they satisfy the legal test at the relevant time. The diagnosis is important evidence, not an automatic answer. Consider the actual symptoms, complexity of the decisions, professional notes and reliable observations around the making of the will.

Is the Mental Capacity Act test now used for every will?

No. Ordinary probate disputes continue to use Banks v Goodfellow under the authorities discussed here. Court-authorised statutory wills involve a different statutory framework. Proposed reform should not be confused with an enacted and commenced change applicable to the disputed document.

Does failing the golden rule invalidate the will?

No. The golden rule concerns protective professional practice. Its omission may leave important evidential gaps and can be relevant to a separate professional negligence issue, but it does not itself decide whether the testator actually had testamentary capacity.

Can medical records prove the case without an expert?

Sometimes the available evidence makes the position sufficiently clear, but an expert may be useful where records are complex or contradictory. Obtain advice about proportionality before commissioning a report. The expert must address the relevant legal questions rather than simply confirm a diagnosis.

Does an irrational gift prove lack of capacity?

No. People may make unusual, unequal or harsh gifts while retaining capacity. Investigate whether the choice reflected a disorder affecting the testamentary decision, a misunderstanding, coercion or a genuinely held preference. Those possibilities should not be conflated in correspondence or pleadings.

Further reading: Clitheroe v Bond [2021] EWHC 1102 (Ch) · Radcliffe Chambers: Capacity test in Clitheroe · Law Society: Kenward v Adams and the golden rule · Law Commission: Wills reform recommendations · Law Commission: Implementation status · CPR Part 57: Probate procedure · Bar Council: Direct Access and responsibility for litigation

Clerk & Counsel is an intermediary and clerking service. We do not provide legal advice or legal representation. Barristers instructed through Clerk & Counsel are independent legal professionals regulated by the Bar Standards Board and are responsible for the legal services they provide. It is free to submit an enquiry; if you instruct a barrister through us, our service fee of up to £150 depending on urgency is shown separately from the barrister's professional fee before you decide.

Related pages

Dispute over an estate?
Request availability and a quote.