Trusts guide · England & Wales

Letter of Wishes: Legal Effect & Disputes

A letter of wishes explains how you would like someone to exercise a discretion or approach practical decisions after your death. It commonly accompanies a discretionary trust or will and may help trustees understand family circumstances that a formal document cannot easily capture. It is normally non-binding: it does not itself transfer property or amend a valid will. That flexibility is useful, but unclear, outdated or accusatory letters can produce disputes rather than prevent them. This guide explains the distinction between wishes and instructions, how pension nominations differ, when beneficiaries may seek disclosure and when specialist advice is useful before a letter is signed or relied upon.

Letter of Wishes: Legal Effect & Disputes

Is a letter of wishes legally binding?

Usually not. Its role is to guide an existing discretion, not to create one or contradict binding obligations. If a will gives an asset outright to a beneficiary, a separate request to share it with others normally cannot compel redistribution. If trustees lack a power to benefit a particular person, a letter cannot add that person to the beneficiary class. The will, deed or scheme rules remain the starting point.

The document's substance and legal context still matter. Calling something a letter of wishes does not conclusively determine whether it creates obligations, and a will may raise questions about incorporating another document. Avoid instructions that assume legal effect without satisfying the necessary formalities. Where a fixed outcome is essential, discuss whether it belongs in a properly executed will, codicil or trust instrument rather than rely on an informal accompanying note.

Using wishes with a discretionary trust

A settlor may explain priorities such as supporting a vulnerable relative, funding education or considering resources available outside the trust. Trustees should consider relevant wishes but must exercise independent judgment for proper purposes. They cannot promise always to follow the settlor's preferences regardless of changing circumstances. A letter should distinguish the reasons for a preference from an attempt to dictate the result of every future request.

Think about the information trustees will genuinely need: family relationships, the purpose of the fund and circumstances that would justify different support. Describe flexibility expressly, including the possibility that circumstances may change after death. Avoid assumptions that every beneficiary's needs are already known. Where a letter recommends unequal benefits, a measured explanation may assist administration; sweeping criticism or unsupported allegations can entrench conflict and distract trustees from their actual duties.

What to include and how to keep it current

Typical contents include identification of the relevant will or trust; the people and relationships being discussed; broad priorities for income and capital; relevant support needs; reasons for significant preferences; and where trustees can find reliable background information. Funeral preferences and personal belongings may also be discussed, but check whether a binding gift or practical arrangement is needed instead. Do not put passwords or unnecessary sensitive medical details into a document likely to circulate during administration.

Date the letter, make its intended non-binding status clear and keep it with the relevant professional records. Review it after major relationship, financial or health changes and tell the intended decision-makers where the current version is held. Manage superseded versions carefully rather than leave several contradictory letters without explanation. If a dispute is foreseeable or has started, preserve evidence and obtain advice before destroying or altering existing documents.

Pensions expressions of wishes are separate

A pension scheme's expression-of-wishes or nomination process concerns death benefits under that scheme, not simply assets passing under a will. Where the scheme gives the decision-maker discretion, a nomination normally guides rather than binds the decision. Other arrangements can operate differently. Ask the provider how the particular benefit works and complete its required process instead of assuming a general letter lodged with a will is enough.

Review nominations after marriage, separation, bereavement or the birth of children, while recognising that scheme rules control who is eligible and what benefits can be paid. Tax treatment is a separate question and can change; do not assume a nomination guarantees a particular Inheritance Tax or Income Tax outcome. Keep legal succession advice separate from regulated financial advice about pension choices, and obtain the appropriate specialist help where both are needed.

Disclosure, executor decisions and disputed letters

Breakspear v Ackland [2008] EWHC 220 (Ch) considered disclosure of wishes in a discretionary trust. It recognised the ordinarily confidential character of such material, but not an absolute immunity from disclosure. Trustees must consider their discretion and the proper administration of the trust, and the court retains supervision. A beneficiary should explain why disclosure is needed; neither beneficiary status nor a confidentiality label automatically determines every request.

An executor must follow the valid will and legal duties, not conflicting wishes. Where the will gives discretion, relevant wishes may inform its exercise without dictating the outcome. A letter can also become evidence in a will-validity dispute, for example about knowledge, capacity or alleged influence, but disagreement with its contents does not invalidate the will. Preserve the original, its provenance, drafts and surrounding communications. Challenges usually concern authenticity, the governing instrument or the decision made, rather than cancelling a non-binding preference in isolation.

Instructing a barrister through Clerk&Counsel

A trusts or Chancery barrister can give a focused opinion on the document, the available remedies and the evidence needed before anyone commits to proceedings. Send the operative documents, a short chronology, relevant accounts and correspondence, and the result you want. Identify any proposed distribution, property sale or court deadline. An initial opinion can help distinguish an arguable legal problem from understandable disappointment and identify whether negotiation is proportionate.

Clerk&Counsel is an intermediary and clerking service, not a provider of legal advice. A free enquiry can lead to an introduction to an independent barrister regulated by the Bar Standards Board, through Public Access where suitable or via a solicitor. Written fixed fee quotes set out the agreed work. A Clerk&Counsel service fee of up to £150, depending on urgency, is shown separately from counsel's professional fee before you decide. Most Public Access barristers do not conduct litigation; check who will handle filing, service and case management.

Cost guide

Estimate the likely cost of a barrister

A broad guide based on fees typically quoted by barristers in England and Wales. Choose the options closest to your case to see a realistic range.

Estimated barrister's fee

£2,000 to £3,350 plus VAT

About £2,400 to £4,000 including VAT at 20%, where the barrister is VAT registered.

What the estimate covers

  • Reading and preparing your papers before the hearing
  • A conference with you beforehand, by phone, video or in person
  • Preparing submissions, a skeleton argument or position statement where needed
  • Attending and representing you at the hearing
  • A short note of the outcome and next steps afterwards

Why your quote may differ

Your quote will depend on which suitable barristers are available for your hearing date. It also depends on how many papers there are, how complex the case is and the amount at stake.

Senior barristers and King's Counsel are usually only needed for complex, high value or specialist cases. Short-notice hearings cost more because the barrister has to clear time to prepare.

Hearings of a week or more, written advice and drafting are quoted individually. Court fees, expert fees and travel are not included.

The Clerk & Counsel service fee of up to £150, depending on urgency, is separate. It is shown alongside the barrister's fee before you decide whether to go ahead. Submitting an enquiry is free.

FAQs

Common questions

Can an executor ignore a letter of wishes?

They must not follow wishes that conflict with the will or legal duties. Where there is a genuine discretion, relevant wishes can inform the decision but are not normally binding. First identify what the executor was actually authorised to decide, rather than assume all administration choices are discretionary.

Can a letter of wishes be challenged?

You can dispute authenticity, relevance or the legality of decisions said to rely on it. Because the letter is usually non-binding, the useful legal target may be a trustee decision or the validity of the will instead. Identify the outcome sought before choosing a procedure.

Do beneficiaries have a right to see it?

Not automatically. Confidentiality, proper administration and the reason for seeking disclosure matter, with the court retaining supervisory powers. Basic trust accounts and a confidential statement of preferences raise different issues. A focused request is generally more useful than assuming unrestricted access to all private papers.

Can I change gifts by writing another letter?

Usually a non-binding letter cannot change binding gifts in a will or trust. If your intended distribution has changed, seek advice on the correct formal document and execution requirements. Leaving contradictory papers can create evidential disputes and unnecessary administration costs for those dealing with the estate.

Does a letter protect a will from challenge?

No. It may explain intentions, but it cannot cure defective execution or prevent investigation of capacity, coercion or another recognised issue. Nor does it prevent an eligible financial provision claim. A careful, contemporaneous professional record may be more useful than a forceful statement that nobody should challenge anything.

Further reading: GOV.UK: Types of trust · High Court judgment: Breakspear v Ackland [2008] EWHC 220 (Ch) · MoneyHelper: Wills, letters of wishes and pension wishes

Clerk & Counsel is an intermediary and clerking service. We do not provide legal advice or legal representation. Barristers instructed through Clerk & Counsel are independent legal professionals regulated by the Bar Standards Board and are responsible for the legal services they provide. It is free to submit an enquiry; if you instruct a barrister through us, our service fee of up to £150 depending on urgency is shown separately from the barrister's professional fee before you decide.

Related pages

Trust, estate or tax question?
Ask for a specialist private client barrister.